Hopefully journals will take action on simonsohn s recommendation to publish raw data, as well as some of the solutions he put forward with his coauthors in psychological science last year aimed at reducing false. Pcurving the evidence psychological science, v285 687693. Older adults tend to be more positive than younger adults about science media coverage. We first ran a pilot study to develop a novel experimental paradigm for studying sequential collaboration online. Psychological science under scrutiny explores a range of contemporary challenges to the assumptions and methodologies of psychology, in order to encourage debate and ground the discipline in solid.
The single most important historical book you can read. She is one of the cofounders of the society for the improvement of psychological science. Scientists are among the most trusted groups internationally. The psychological science accelerator psa is a distributed network of. Video data and documentation will improve psychological science. Some quick guidelines are provided for use in figuring out when. The authors of the reportjoseph simmons and uri simonsohn of penn and. Advances in methods and practices in psychological science 1 4, 538555. Nelson and uri simonsohn anything as significant falsepositive psychology. Uri simonsohn, behavioral scientist, w harton school of business carney based her revised analysis on failed replications of the data and her hindsight view that she and fellow researchers engaged. Chronological rejuvenation is psychological jargon for the fountain of youth. Methodological issues and strategies in clinical research. These will be supplemented by popular press articles and multimedia resources such as podcasts and video clips specific to class periods and topics.
Simonsohn points to the possibility that a higher percentage. Apr 30, 2019 indeed, this relates to the justly celebrated work of simmons, nelson, and simonsohn on researcher degrees of freedom and false positive psychology. Social psychologys most prestigious journal, the journal of personality and social psychology, publishedanarticlebydarylbem2011inwhichhepresentednineexperimentssupporting a transparently outlandish claimthat people can be in. The best presentation of the science and applications of psychology. The effect of power posing on personal success has been the. A very wellwritten summary of the state of the art circa the late 90s across much of cognitive science, written from an evolutionary psychology perspective, for the layreader. Its quite fitting that the first point on this list is about the importance of being first. Shlomo simonsohn is the author of jews in sicily, volume 12 3. Psychologys renaissance wharton faculty platform university of. Simonsohns fraud detection technique revealed david.
My recent book shows that 40 years of social psychological science data actually shows the exact opposite of what it is generally claimed to show. Psychological science publishes cuttingedge empirical research of broad interest and theoretical. First, we show that despite empirical psychologists nominal. Sep 18, 2016 uri simonsohn just turned down the chance to publish a paper that couldve been published in a top journal a couple years ago idve said psychological science but recently theyve somewhat cleaned up their act, so lets say ppnas which seems to be still going strong followed by features in npr, major newspapers, boingboing, and all the rest. Perspectives on psychological science sage publications ltd. Jun 16, 2012 yet uri simonsohn of the university of pennsylvania and francesca gino at harvard report in psychological science that this is not how things work out in practice. Sep 29, 2020 about eightinten in singapore 80% and south korea 77% also say the news media do a good job covering science. Biological p70 simmons j p nelson l d simonsohn u 2011 false. A practical guide for transparency in psychological science. Routledge and crc press psychological science books. Simonsohns fraud detection technique revealed david nussbaum.
Pcurving a more comprehensive body of research on postural. A social psychological model of scientific practices. Simmons, j p, nelson, l d and simonsohn, u 2014 data from paper falsepositive psychology. Bad science practices psychology bibliographies cite.
Dec 06, 2018 an example of this is the psychological science accelerator, which runs studies simultaneously at labs around the globe to produce bigger data sets with a more diverse pool of study subjects than. Biological psychiatry 66 864870 simmons j p nelson l d simonsohn u 2011 false from mcb 80 at harvard university. Simmons, j p, nelson, l d and simonsohn, u 2014 data from paper falsepositive p sychology. Psychologys replication crisis has made the field better. Thinking, fast and slow hardcover by daniel kahneman. Hes the author of several books including forms of life. Spurious also namesimilarity effects implicit egotism in. The scientific critique of mostly psychological science. These projects can focus on novel research questions, or attempt to. Jun 02, 2016 society for personality and social psychology 1,119 views. Simonsohn initially targeted not flagrant dishonesty, but loose methodology.
Jan 19, 2016 in a post from may 2015, psychology researchers joe simmons and uri simonsohn analyzed the original powerpose study and its unsuccessful replication in detail, writing the powerposing. The effect of power posing on personal success has been. Simmons uri simonsohn psychological science christian jarrett pseudoscience poppsych psychology reproducing studies flawed studies research digest popular surprising science. Wray herberts book, on second thought, has recently been. Undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting. Jan 03, 2017 psychological science under scrutiny explores a range of contemporary challenges to the assumptions and methodologies of psychology, in order to encourage debate and ground the discipline in solid. Scientific freedom and the fountain of youth association for. Harry collins is a distinguished research professor of social science at cardiff university, specializing in scientific knowledge. Shlomo simonsohn author of jews in sicily, volume 12. Jul 12, 2012 next week, simonsohn plans to submit a paper to psychological science documenting the full statistical techniques that he used to investigate smeesters and sanna, along with his code and data. Oct 01, 2016 uri simonsohn, behavioral scientist, w harton school of business carney based her revised analysis on failed replications of the data and her hindsight view that she and fellow researchers engaged.
Alan kazdins edited compilation of readings, methodological issues and strategies in clinical research miscr, is a classic, and for good reason. Skepticism, not dismissal, is justified by flaws in science. The history of the jews in sicily covers a period of over a thousand years, from antiquity to the expulsion, based on some 40,000 archival records, most of them hitherto unpublished. It illustrates the political, legal, economic, social and religious vicissitudes of the jewish minority and its relations with the surrounding majority of romans. Barbara simonsohn is the author of barley grass juice 4. Its three prior editions have long served as onestop shopping resources for advanced undergraduates, graduate students, and faculty members hoping to consult the best articles bearing on methodological issues and advances in clinical.
Biological p70 simmons j p nelson l d simonsohn u 2011. Drawing on teaching and learning research, the sixth edition provides new tools to improve students reading, focus, and selfassessment. Falsepositive psychology by simmons, nelson, simonsohn. The aim of this course is to help students master the particular techniques and tools needed to conduct research in social psychology, including conducting social psychological experiments, working in the field and crossculturally, and collecting quantitative and qualitative data.
Apr 01, 2021 psychological science publishes cuttingedge empirical research of broad interest and theoretical. View our complete catalog of authoritative psychological science related book titles and textbooks published by routledge and crc press. Cultural differences might account for the discrepancy. Chapters are now divided into brief study units, each of which concludes with a selftest question to increase comprehension. Such issues are particularly relevant given the recent emphasis on replicability and best practices in psychological science klein et al. The various overestimated effects in the psychological science pnas canon can be viewed as a big social experiment in which noisy data and noisy statistics were, until recently, taken as evidence that we live in a capricious social world, and that were buffeted by all sorts of large effects. Course catalogue research methods in social psychology. Readings will include journal articles and book chapters. In a paper called falsepositive psychology, published in the prestigious journal psychological science, he and. Perspectives on psychological science sage publications inc. The statistical crisis in science and how to move forward by professor andrew. First, we show that despite empirical psychologists nominal endorsement of a low rate of falsepositive findings. Falsepositive psychology undisclosed flexibility in data collection and analysis allows presenting anything as significant. Psychological research is sometimes, but not always, highly credible.
827 629 462 1677 50 907 1397 1799 700 837 986 1141 43 1200 829 504 669 904 401 917 37 1169 638 183 1672 525 1115 656 893 94